Cherry Street is a good place to solve the familiar problem of wanting to go out without wanting to organize an entire occasion. Start with the kind of evening you need. A pizza to share, a coffee and pastry, and a dinner you want to sit over are different plans, even when the addresses are close together.
These eight stops give you a few ways into the neighborhood. This is a guide to choosing, not a claim that we have eaten every dish or secretly ranked every table. The food details below come from the businesses’ own sites. Menus change, so use the links to check the current version before a particular dish becomes the reason for the trip.
For a group, settle the budget and dietary requirements before choosing a restaurant. It is less awkward than sorting it out after everyone is seated. Check the venue’s booking options, and read the signs wherever you park. We have left out unverified parking shortcuts and prices rather than promising a convenience that might not exist.
01 / Andolini’s Pizzeria
Andolini’s Cherry Street location is at 1552 E. 15th St. Its published menu includes the DeMarco of Brooklyn, made with tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and basil. That is a sensible starting point if you want a pizza whose ingredients you can recognize without decoding a long description.
For a group, decide on the pies together before everyone disappears into the menu. Ask about size and dietary substitutions directly rather than assuming one pizza will suit every person. We would choose this as the meal itself, with a walk afterward if the weather cooperates, instead of treating it as the first stop in a food marathon.
02 / Coffee House on Cherry Street
Coffee House on Cherry Street is at 1502 E. 15th St. The business describes coffee, breakfast and pastries, plus gluten-free and vegan options. That makes it worth checking when your group wants a lower-key catch-up or when a full dinner is more than the afternoon calls for.
An advertised dietary option is a starting point for a conversation, especially if you have an allergy. Ask about the specific item and preparation you need. For everyone else, the useful decision is simpler: choose a drink, look at what is available that day, and give yourself time to finish both without having to rush to the next reservation.
03 / Nola’s Creole & Cocktails
Nola’s lists its address as 1334 E. 15th St. and describes its food through the mix of traditions behind Creole cooking. If the group wants a different direction from pizza or a burger, this gives you a concrete option to put on the table rather than another round of vague suggestions.
Read the current menu before you choose and ask the restaurant about any ingredient concerns. Do not assume a familiar dish name tells you everything about how it is prepared. Our approach would be to make this the anchor of the evening, with enough time to order at your own pace instead of fitting dinner between two other plans.
04 / SMOKE. Woodfire Grill
SMOKE. describes its cooking around a woodfire grill and slow-smoking, with menus that change seasonally. TravelOK lists its Cherry Street location at 1542 E. 15th St. That gives you a clear option for a dinner organized around the kitchen’s cooking style rather than one permanent signature dish.
Check the current menu, then book if the restaurant offers a time that suits your group. A seasonal menu is a reason to stay curious, not a reason to promise someone an item you saw in an old photograph. If you are celebrating, make the occasion clear when you contact the restaurant and let them explain the available arrangements.
05 / Prossimo Ristorante
Prossimo’s own site emphasizes handmade pasta and describes a tableside Il Vero Alfredo presentation using fettuccine and Parmigiano Reggiano. That is a specific reason to consider it when you want dinner to have a little ceremony. Check that the presentation is available for the service you are booking.
This is the option we would put forward when the point is spending time at the table. Leave room in the plan for that. If you are choosing between a hurried early sitting and a later one you can enjoy properly, discuss the timing with your group before making the booking. A good dinner plan begins before the first course.
06 / Roosevelt’s
Roosevelt’s is at 1551 E. 15th St. Its published menu includes the Roosemelt with brie, Havarti and smoked gouda, as well as burgers and a vegetarian bean burger. That range is useful when nobody quite agrees on what dinner should be, but everyone agrees they would like to stop debating it.
Use the menu to narrow the choice before arriving, then check the current offerings at the table. If you are drawn to a seasonal item, make sure you are reading the right service menu. We would choose a main first and let the rest follow, rather than ordering a collection of starters because deciding feels too difficult.
07 / Hideaway Pizza
Hideaway’s Cherry Street location lists 1419 E. 15th St., a four-season patio and curbside pickup among its features. Those are useful distinctions if you are deciding between going out and taking dinner home. The restaurant’s own page also provides a waitlist link, which is worth checking before committing everyone to a departure time.
Two pizza restaurants can belong in the same neighborhood guide without requiring a winner. Choose the format that fits the day: the menu you want, the pickup arrangement you need, or the table you can actually get. The important part is that everyone knows the plan before they are hungry and circling the block.
08 / Sidecar Barley & Wine Bar
Sidecar’s Cherry Street location is at 1515 E. 15th St., Suite 501. Its official page describes a rooftop setting with views across Tulsa and seasonal patio music. Think of this as the optional drink stop in your food plan, rather than assuming it replaces a full dinner without checking the menu.
Look at the weather before deciding that an outdoor table is essential. Check the current event information if live music matters to you; seasonal programming is not a promise for every evening. If you have already had the meal and conversation you wanted, it is also fine to end there. Save the rooftop for a night when you have time to enjoy it.
Make room for Tulsa in your inbox. Get our free Friday newsletter.